It is Not Words That Shake Me Thus - Literature Essay Samples

Othello is, among other things, a play about words. Each characters essence is expressed by a distinct idiom, and each character succeeds or fails, at least to an extent, because of language. A passage in the temptation scene, 3.3.191-222, demonstrates how Iago uses language to manipulate Othello, and how Othellos language in turn expresses his descent from reason into jealousy. This passage is a provocative example of how, in Othello, words not only express but actually create the characters shifting realities. One of the major ironies of Othello is that most of its characters are unable to acknowledge the hidden meanings of words; as a result, they remain ignorant of the language-generated scripts they are following. Iago is the only character fully capable of deconstructing language and using it for manipulative purposes (Hall 45). In his efforts to convince Othello of his wifes infidelity, Iago uses language to create an air of intimate confidence. His tone is falsely caring as h e plants suspicions in Othellos heart: now I shall have reason / To show the love and duty that I bear you / With franker spirit (3.3.193-95).Iagos self-serving repetition of I hope you will consider what is spoke / Comes from my love (3.3.216) furthers Othellos feeling of reassurance. In order to appear even more earnest, he feigns hesitation with lines like I speak not yet of proof and I humbly do beseech you of your pardon / For too much loving you (3.3.196, 214). This pretense of sincerity coupled with humility makes his adultery theories about Desdemona all the more convincing.His tentativeness also invites responses from Othello and thus enables Iago to check the progress of his manipulation. Iago uses language not only to give himself the illusion of credibility, but to create a bond between himself and Othello. In this passage, Iagos speech is elevated to match the quality of Othellos speech and thereby win his trust. This unnaturally elevated language is a contrast to his prose idiom, which is more in keeping with his coarse nature. (The only other two characters to speak in prose are Desdemona and the clown. Prose is assigned to the clown to reflect his lower social rank; Desdemona uses prose in moments meant to emphasize her pure nature. ) An example of Iagos coarse language can be found in Act Two, Scene Three when he speaks to Cassio of Desdemona: Ill warrant her full of gameà ¢Ã‚ ¤|What an eye she has! Methinks it sounds a parley to provocationà ¢Ã‚ ¤|Well, happiness to their sheets! Come, lieutenant, / I have a stoup of wine, and here without are a / brace of Cyprus gallants that would fain have a measure to the health of black Othello (19-29). This is contrasted with the delicate nature of his speech in lines 215-20 of the temptation passage: I hope you will consider what is spoke / Comes from my love. But I do see y are moved. / I am to pray you not to strain my speech / To grosser issues, nor to larger reach / Than to suspicion. Not only p rose but also soliloquies and asides are absent from lines 3.3.191-222. Nor are there any interruptions to this scheming and one-sided dialogue. Presumably these kinds of cues to the audience would distract from the growing intimacy between the two men.The blank verse Iago uses instead creates a concentrated atmosphere of emotional connection between Othello and Iago, which culminates in Othellos declaration in line 215: I am bound to thee forever. In Act Three, Scene Four, the bond is formally staged through the symbolic exchange of wedding vows between the kneeling knave Iago and his victim Othello (Hall 47).As the passage continues, Othellos psychological transformation is evident in the words he speaks or does not speak. The first thing to note about Othellos reactionary language in the passage is not its quality but its quantity.Despite his reputation and overall prominence, Othello speaks only eight of the passages thirty-one lines. The first three of Othellos lines introduce a motif of the passage: the erasure of his doubt. The rest are simple responses or echoes of Iagos manipulations: Dost thou say so?; And so she did; I will not. All show Othellos weakening spirit and compliant tone. I am bound to thee forever in line 213 similarly echoes Iago, who in line 195 introduced the notion that the two men are bound in fates. Othellos Not a jot, not a jot of line 215 recalls Iago in line thirty-six when he says, Nothing, my lord; of if-I know not what. The repetition of nothingness and contradictions allows us to see more clearly the impotency of Othello before Iagos overwhelming verbal and emotional assaults. Iago is a miserable man and knows I am not what I am (2.3.42). Now he shares his sense of nothingness with his noble lord. In 3.3.106, Othello exclaims to Iago: By heaven, thou echoest me. Of course, the reverse is true; as Othello falls under Iagos spell, his language increasingly resembles Iagos. For example, we see the tone of irony Othello has bo rrowed from Iago. Ironic language was inconsistent with the self-assured identity Othello used to possess, but now that jealousy has taken hold of him, he can cry things like, I am abused, and my relief / Must be to loathe her. O curse of marriage / That we call these delicate creatures ours, / And not their appetites! (3.3.267-269). An example of Othello mirroring Iagos language appears in 207-8: She loved them most. / And so she did. Another instance of echoing is in lines 195 and 213 respectively. Iago states: as I am bound to which Othello replies I am bound to thee forever. From this bond, insinuations are able to clutter the Moors once open mind. Iagos commanding Why go to then! speeds the closing of his devilish trap (3.3.208). Lying is another of the passages motifs. Ironically, Iago, the man who is misleading Othello, advises Othello against being blinded to the truth. He reminds Othello of his blackness by visualizing Desdemona seeming to shake and fear [his] looks (3.3.2 07). Next, he warns that Desdemona was able to seel her fathers eyes up close as oak (3.3.210) and alludes to the falconry practice of sewing up hawks eyes. A further irony is that Othello begins the passage with a declaration of his commitment to the truth: Ill see before I doubt; when I doubt, prove; / And on the proof there is no more but this: / Away at once with love or jealousy! (3.3.191-193). Gradually, however, Othello takes on the language of a dissembler by lying to himself or at least his former identity. Whereas Iago is able to conceal his cunning by denouncing his own actions, Othello is an inexperienced liar. He learns to lie by echoing the thoughts of Iago. Since the passage addressed comes at the beginning of Othellos negative transformation, his language has not yet completely deteriorated. However, a suggestion of his forthcoming speech-habits appears in line 191, where his use of the doublet reflects his anxiety: Ill see before I doubt; when I doubt, prove. He i s in effect reduced to a stammer. The final results of the transformation, which began in the temptation scene, are revealed in lines 299 and 339 of Act Five, Scene Two. Iago, satiated with the success of his words, affirms that From this time forth never will [I] speak a word. The completeness of Othellos transformation is underscored as he calls out a warning: Then must you speak / of one that loved not wisely, but too well. The subtext of this line is that Brabantios statement: But words are words is wrong (1.3.215). Thus the tragedy concludes with a bold, if belated, acknowledgment of the power of language. The words alone are the play. Works Cited Hall, Joan. Othello: A Guide to the Play. London: Greenwood Press, 1999. Shakespeare, William. Othello. New York: Signet, 1998.